Five Things That Make It Easier
You don’t need a perfect system before you buy your first piece of gold or silver. But a little awareness up front prevents a lot of future frustration.
Here are the five things that really helped me. I didn’t always get it right, but I recognised my mistakes and adjusted over time.
1. Track your stack from day one
Set up a simple spreadsheet the day you make your first purchase. Include:
Date
Item description
Weight (grams or ounces)
What you paid
The spot price that day
Who you bought it from
Where it’s stored
Future you will thank present you when it comes time to sell, gift, or simply remember what you actually own and what it’s now worth in dollars.
I love updating the spot price and watching the total value change. It’s like having my own bank account, which has been valuable for me psychologically. Before I bought metals, a lot of my sense of personal value came from the balance in my bank account. Being able to open the spreadsheet and see that my net worth still exists has been important. Watching the number move keeps me sane.
Recommended: keep these records as a file on your own computer. No apps. No cloud. No trace.
2. Coins, bars or collectables?
This is personal preference, but beginners usually do best chasing the lowest premium (closest to spot).
That generally means bars or unlimited-edition rounds and coins (Kangaroos, Krugerrands, Liberties, etc.).
Gold is gold. Silver is silver. Spot is spot. Everything above spot is dealer premium, and premium eats into your profit before you’ve even bought the metal.
There are strong secondary markets for collectible coins, but you need to be active in those circles to sell them at full value. For example, if I take my beautiful Honey Bee coin (with its enamel design and presentation box) to a dealer or pawn shop, they will only pay me the value of the metal. A collector, however, will pay significantly more because only 2,000 were minted — it’s rare and highly collectable. These pieces can be worthwhile, but they’re niche. I wouldn’t recommend them as a starting purchase.
To begin with, pay attention to what bullion dealers will pay you when you want to sell. They are usually your easiest off-ramp.
3. Weight and size
Small pieces (1 gram or 1/10 oz) are less stressful and easier to sell later if you need cash quickly. They do, however, carry a higher premium (higher cost per ounce).
Larger bars (for example, 10 oz) have a much lower cost per ounce, but they are a bigger outlay and can be harder to sell quickly.
Personally, I like big silver bars and small gold coins for long-term stacking. I also stay aware of how high gold could go and try to keep individual pieces well under $10k so they stay easier to offload for cash later.
For example, in 2023 I bought a 100g gold bar. At the time it was just under $10k. That mattered to me because I wanted to pay cash without the purchase being reported to Austrac.
Fast forward to now, and that bar is worth significantly more than $10k. When I sell it, a dealer will need to report the transaction. If I sell it privately, the buyer will need to come up with $19k or more. That’s a substantial sum for most individuals to have ready in one go (not impossible, but it narrows the pool).
I’m going to do a longer blog on this topic, as there is a lot to say. But for this blog, I’m keeping it simple. This blog is designed to make your first purchases straightforward.
4. Storage
You don’t need to solve this perfectly today, but it becomes more important as your stack grows. Keep storage in mind — your needs will change over time.
Common options:
Under the mattress / at home
Home safe
Safe deposit box
White-glove professional vaulting service
They serve different purposes. If you’re buying for an SMSF, full white-glove vaulting is mandatory.
My strong personal views:
I will never put my metals in a bank safety deposit box. If you read the fine print, anything stored in a bank’s facilities is treated as the bank’s property. The counterparty risk is effectively the same as leaving cash in a bank account. Just don’t.
Don’t burden other people with the knowledge of where your metals are or how much you have. It’s not their job to keep your secrets. This obviously excludes the people in your inner circle who genuinely need to know about access if you are incapacitated.
Eventually, include details of where and how to access them in your will.
5. Keep your receipts
Photograph or scan them and store the originals somewhere separate from the metal if you can. They prove what you paid (useful for tax) and that you bought from a legitimate dealer.
I’ve made several purchases directly from other stackers privately (I’m in a stacker group — more on those later). For those purchases, I have no receipts, which is fine. But if you do buy from a dealer, having the paperwork is highly desirable.
Final thought
Start simple. Track what you buy. Choose pieces you can actually hold and sell. Keep the paperwork. Your stack becomes much easier to manage when you treat it like an ongoing plan instead of a series of one-off purchases.
If you are ready to take the leap and buy, I’ve created a list of Bullion Dealers that I know and trust. You can access that list here.
This essay is intended as entertainment and for education, not personal financial advice. Your decisions are yours.
Do your own research and consult a licenced financial adviser before making any financial decisions.